August 21, 2008
-
Why increasing the minimum wage sucked.
Disclosure: This post will be written not even taking into account the argument of inflation. Additionally, it will focus entirely on one perspective.Here’s a complete breakdown of how minimum wage increases cause more problems than they solve as seen through the eyes of a fast food manager.
The problem all starts off with this notion by the employees that all of a sudden they are going to be getting more money, because sadly, this isn’t true. The amount of money that the hourly employees who were affected by minimum wage receive
in their paychecks will effectively remain the same. In fact, employees who were already above the new minimum wage increase are actually now receiving less money than they did in the first place. In layman’s terms, I will give you my prognosis as to why.
First of all, the amount of money that the employees gets depends entirely on how much money our store earns in a shift. Seeing as how their money comes off of our store’s earnings for that shift, if we aren’t making money, we can’t afford to have them clocked in. There is a number that I have to keep track of on a minute-by-minute basis that is called “labor”. This number is a percentage of how much of our incoming profit will be going directly to the employees who are working that hour’s paychecks. If that number is above 18, meaning that more than 18% of the money we are making is going to the hourlies, I have to send people home. Just because minimum wage is going up doesn’t mean more people are going to come and buy our food, therefor, since we are paying the employees more now than we were before, th
e labor number is more likley to go up, which means the employees are more likely to go home. This of course means, they are getting less hours.
That is just the first problem. The second problem is a direct result of the first. Since the employees are getting less hours, that means we have fewer employees on the clock at a time than we did before the minimum wage. We used to have 8-9 employees clocked in at a time, and now that number has been reduced to 6 if barely. However, the number of customers we get remains fairly constant, we still receive just as many orders per shift. This means that the people on the shift have to actually work harder than they did before. The short of this is that THE EMPLOYEES ARE WORKING HARDER AND ACTUALLY GETTING LESS MONEY. To say that this hurts morale is un understatement. Six employees have walked out (that’s walked out not quit) in the short one month that has passed since minimum wage went up.
This brings us to the third problem, which is actually a direct result of the second problem (see how this all kind of snowballs). The fact that the workers are
having to work harder, get less money, and not be as enthusiastic about working for a company that doesn’t seem to care about them has a direct impact on quality of service. Even if the employees were all balls-to-the-wall about getting their work done, the fact that there are less employees simply means the food won’t be getting out as quickly. When the food doesn’t get out as quickly, and even when it does get out, it appears to have been made sloppily, we begin to lose customers. When we begin to lose customers, the store begins to lose money, because if there aren’t as many customers per shift, then we don’t make as much per shift. I’m sure you have probably guessed what comes next. If we start making less money per shift, then that pesky labor number is going to start to climb again, and we start our whole problem back over.
In conclusion, minimum wage has begun a downward spiral that may cause problems for many businesses.I hope this is one storm we can weather otherwise these grapes are gonna start to get a little wrath-y.
Until next time, good luck with life.
Comments (36)
Want some fries with that?
…like, so that I don’t lose my job.
Yeah, we only have two people (1 manager and 1 “associate”) in the store most times. Sometimes we get 3 and we are ecstatic. We’re supposed to suggest other things to go with what the people have found as well. You know, while cutting fabric we ask what the project is and suggest other bits and pieces, or we give the person walking around with 2 or 3 items a basket so they can carry more things more easily. Anything we can do to help people spend unimaginable amounts of money….
Aha. That movie scene is from fast food nation. I like that movie.
Sighs. The gas is causing all these problems. Plus in ca all the good state jobs had their hours cut and pay lowered to mini wage.
Xo
yay, (i mean nooo or…) this mean i’ll never get a job this year (or ever?)
Aww. Talk about the world. I’m afraid to age.
dude, you just touched one of the basic economic principles of libertarianism!
well done, you have officially earned my hardcore respect for this very well written piece.
“when the government uses it’s power to stimulate the economy, it often has unintended and perverse consequences, it is much better to let the market control itself.”
I seriously hope you can explain this to your co-workers the same way you did in this blog.
well done.
To say that this hurts morale is un understatement. is the ”un” real thing, not ”an”? no , i think ”un” is more damned than damn.
=)
LOLERZZZ!!
it’s the price floor stuff =/ min. wage is bad in the economic perspective anyways =/ work force should get paid with what they deserve not effing min. wage. >:[
First off, let me concede everything you have said as true. However, the reasons for raising the minimum wage are also pressures to change buisness models to force businesses to pay people so they can live.
Although not economic, my argument is based on the premise that if you are going to work somebody 40 hours a week, you should pay them enough to where they can live off of what you give them. The standard of living should be considered a market force, one that is ignored by to many companies.
Everybody likes to bash on Walmart in this aspect…. I’m no exception. Here is a URL with some damaging statistics an Walmart, and I suspect are true for the fast food and retail industries.
http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Corporate_Welfare/WalMart_Welfare.html
Walmart employees are amongst the highest in the industry for being on welfare or state run health programs because of Walmart’s low pay and horrible benefits. Because of this, various states, local and federal government money is indirectly subsidizing Walmart because of it’s crappy business model.
Just because a business model works doesn’t make it right. The plantation business model works just fine, but slavery was abolished because it was wrong. Slavery is gone, but if there was no minimum wage, I am sure within 100 years business would find a way to bring a form of it back.
You ceded that your post was written without taking into account inflation. I ask you to consider inflation. According to your business model, inflation is a good thing. I say this because as prices rise, so do revenue (assuming flat sales). If wages stay stagnet, inflation eventually allows you to hire another worker. Your job gets easier, but you don’t bring anything else home, but the business’s profit stays the same.
Chances are, back in 1996, your labor number may have been around 21 or 22, and it has slowly fallen to 18 because why would your company want you to hire another worker if a skeleton crew can get it done? They would rather have inflationary forces help them. In order to function as a business and be in compliance with the law your company may have to raise the labor number back to a higher level. I think McDonalds and Walmart will survive if they open half as many new stores as they did in the last year.
Oh, by the way, that is a very well written post that you wrote. I think the point I am trying to make is that there is more to consider than just the business model when contemplating the issues of employee compensation (not just the minimum wage).
Boy, I don’t miss working hourly jobs any more.
Oh you sound so Libertarian in this post! Unfortunately there is probably going to be a lot of pressure for the government to raise the minimum wage even more due to the bad economy. Another point is that by raising the minimum wage, a lot of companies can’t afford to have as many workers as they once did because they have to pay higher wages.
I am gone for a little while, I come back and you have changed your name?!
What is the world coming to?
when i first started reading this, i didn’t know what to think. but then i gave it a chance and realized you were right making a valid point. yikes.
once again. High quality stuff from one of my most favoritest bloggers.
EDUCATE EM EADIE
we haven’t been affected as much by it because our lowest starting wage is 8.50 anyway, but i still definitely agree, bro. Raising minimum wage is fucktardedness. plus as you said, this hasn’t even taken into consideration the inflation argument. ugh. people.
-Patrick-
Yessss… thank you… At least someone has a brain..
I’m getting above minimum wage now, but when the raise goes into effect here, I won’t get the raise to keep me over it…
There goes my savings plan…
@TheMandarinKing - Unless you get cut both places…? It seems highly plausible that would happen.
@TheMandarinKing - thats not exactly true, for many of my employees, this is their only full time job, and they are still getting minimum wage.
The economy sucks. Raising the minimum wage, cutting taxes, and sending everyone “stimulation checks” isn’t going to solve anything. The foundation of the economy is in danger.
But I don’t see this post as libertarian… just practical. I wouldn’t agree with an entirely maverick market, which libertarians espouse.
it’s terrible. i’m making waaaay over min wage and still having a hard time keeping up with the bills and it doesn’t seem to be getting any better. a little off subject but basically, the entire economy sucks right now.
so thats why I’m always asked if I’d like a drink with that…
Eadie, I had no idea that this was the way fast food worked. I (was) worked (to death) in retail for about nine years and the economy wasn’t bad at the time. We never ran numbers to send anyone home. If it was a dead night, someone (happily) volunteered to leave. But wow. Very well-written.
Am I alone in thinking that if the government has to interfere with the economy, that it should pour money into small businesses instead? It would allow them to grow into larger businesses allowing them to hire more people. It’s one of those long term fixes though. Hard to see the end of it.
I couldn’t have paid my real estate taxes without that stimulus check and I’ve worked a few min wage jobs, but still there has to be a better way.
@theScalesandtheScorpion - This is all true, but first of all, even if inflation was taken into account, it could actually result in lower income still because when the items begin to cost more, customers could begin to buy less. In the end, that could hurt sales even more. Additionally, even if inflation were to balance out all the issues given here in this post, that’s all it would be is a balancing act. Meaning, that raising the minimum wage would have never had to have been done in the first place because it ultimately wouldn’t affect how the employees were spending their money. It’s all perspective though, and everything here in this posts are actual issues that I have had to deal with as a manager in the last month.
I dunno if any of your other commenters have mentioned this, but the other rate increase = suckage is general merchandise prices go up. Factory workers now get paid more so the cost of labor is higher. Cost of product is now higher and we ALL buy products. So now EVERYTHING we buy costs more meaning we get less money from this “rate increase”.
There’s a famous phrase from my childhood:”It costs me more and more money every time my paycheck goes up.”
But wage increases look great on paper.
@life_by_us - That’s called inflation, which I mentioned that I wasn’t even going to include in this article, but I know exactly what you mean.
Shit man, you need the luck, not us, being right in the middle of that cycle.
This is why I’m just gonna be a rockstar instead.
Wow, that was amazing. I never thought of it that way before, and that’s not something I say often. Down with the minimum wage!
Wow! Great post! I don’t think people realize the true impact that increasing the minimum wage has, I know I sure didn’t! and that’s not good.
@RockOfEadie - That’s hilarious. =]
And if you added an inflation argument, having to pay people more will raise prices, making everyone’s relative earnings less…
dude I’m sorry to hear about how stuff is changing at work for you. what do you think should be done to help the situation (politically/economically)?
I’m a bum and don’t have a job- well I have a part time job now doing research, but it’s mostly because I can’t afford the time to work more than that if I want to pass my classes…
@CrazyXBeautifulXDisaster - People are changing their names left and right… it’s pure madness!
wow never thought of it htat way
omg how ironic. i walked out on my job last week sat for that. i was getting less hours even though it was paying me above minimum wage. in the end i was make next to nothing. i train pass for the month ($136)and a bus card for the month($70) was one of my checks after 2 weeks. cafe to say- counter-productive.